If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


review of scientific and news articles on dna testing and popular genetics

Surprises in English and Irish DNA

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Over a year ago, there appeared one of the few studies of autosomal DNA in Ireland and Britain. If you have English/Welsh, Irish, northern Irish, Highlands Scottish, Lowlands Scottish or Swedish matches, you will want to read this post. Here is the original article and abstract.

Eur J Hum Genet. 2010 Nov;18(11):1248-54. Epub 2010 Jun 23.

Population structure and genome-wide patterns of variation in Ireland and Britain.


Located off the northwestern coast of the European mainland, Britain and Ireland were among the last regions of Europe to be colonized by modern humans after the last glacial maximum. Further, the geographical location of Britain, and in particular of Ireland, is such that the impact of historical migration has been minimal. Genetic diversity studies applying the Y chromosome and mitochondrial systems have indicated reduced diversity and an increased population structure across Britain and Ireland relative to the European mainland. Such characteristics would have implications for genetic mapping studies of complex disease. We set out to further our understanding of the genetic architecture of the region from the perspective of (i) population structure, (ii) linkage disequilibrium (LD), (iii) homozygosity and (iv) haplotype diversity (HD). Analysis was conducted on 3654 individuals from Ireland, Britain (with regional sampling in Scotland), Bulgaria, Portugal, Sweden and the Utah HapMap collection. Our results indicate a subtle but clear genetic structure across Britain and Ireland, although levels of structure were reduced in comparison with average cross-European structure. We observed slightly elevated levels of LD and homozygosity in the Irish population compared with neighbouring European populations. We also report on a cline of HD across Europe with greatest levels in southern populations and lowest levels in Ireland and Scotland. These results are consistent with our understanding of the population history of Europe and promote Ireland and Scotland as relatively homogenous resources for genetic mapping of rare variants.

Though the focus was on genome-wide association studies (GWAS) and linkage disequilibrium, or medical aspects of DNA, this study was groundbreaking in using supercomputing and has enormous implications for the history of the British Isles. It used data from over 3,000 individuals from seven populations:

1. Ireland/Dublin

2. Scotland/Aberdeen

3. Bulgaria

4. Portugal

5. Sweden

6. South/Southeast England

7. Utah

Data came from several sources:  the International Schizophrenia Consortium, Wellcome Trust Cast Control Consortium 1958 Birth Control Data set, Utah European ancestry population (CEU) and HapMap project.

The study aimed to describe, statistically, four measures of the Irish and English populations: 

1. Population structure

2. Linkage disequilibrium, with consequences for the study of common Irish and English genetic disorders

3. ROH, or runs of homozygosity, essentially a reflection of inbreeding and the remoteness of a population

4. Haplotype diversity (based on SNPs in atDNA)

The main conclusion was that Irish/English formed a separate and unique population since the Ice Age very different from either Bulgarian (SE Europe) or Portuguese (SW Europe), with great affinities to Sweden or Scandinavian populations (p. 1250). For instance, "the breakdown and patterning of LD [linkage disequilibrium] ... is virtually indistinguishable among the Irish, Scottish, southern English, Swedish..." (p. 1250).

"Diversity across Britain and Ireland is reduced in comparison with mainland European populations, with Scotland and Ireland having lower levels than southern England (p. 1251)."

The study postulates that Irish and English proneness to genetic disease came about as a result of population stasis or unchanging conditions. The agricultural revolution swept in a lot of additions to the gene pool in most of Europe, including Southeast England, but in areas like Ireland, Scotland and Sweden the same population stayed on the land with little increase, in fact with a negative effect during the Norse migrations of the 10th century and the Irish Potato Famine. The study mentions a "kinship effect" apparent in Irish and Scottish clan histories (p. 1254).

The surprising suggestion is that there will now be a groundswell of research into "Irish" and "Scottish" and "English" diseases comparable to Jewish diseases.

A related study is:

A. Auton, K. Bryc, A. Boyko, K. Lohmueller, J. Novembre, A. Reynolds, A. Indap, M. H. Wright, J. Degenhardt, R. Gutenkunst, K. S. King, M. R. Nelson and C. D. Bustamante, Global distribution of genomic diversity underscores rich complex history of continental human populations, Genome Research, February 2009. Abstract.


Stephanie Hayward commented on 27-May-2011 09:15 AM

I am reading the book "When Scotland was Jewish" and am also doing research on the mythical Milesians. Was wondering if this mythical Irish group had ever come up in your discussions. It is said they were descended from Jewish line and I started making
a connection by what is outlined in your book. By the way, the book is great! Stephanie

Teresa Panther-Yates commented on 08-Jun-2011 03:12 PM

How interesting! The Milesians are thought to be one of the mythical populations that started Ireland. They are thought to be Middle-Eastern and from Spain, but this population is not in the book and has not come up. Thank you for this adding this observation.
Teresa P. Yates

Brian Costello commented on 19-Jul-2012 11:39 PM

I can believe that Scots and English have some genetic relationship to the populations of Sweden and / or Norway. They look basically Germanic. However, the Irish are not a Germanic people at all and therefore must descend from a different gene pool, and
I don't think it is one from Spain either.

Peter O'Connor commented on 26-Jun-2013 12:41 PM

I support Bob Quinn's contention that the Irish and (West British) populations came via the sea - and from North Africa - via Spain.
The language, music, culture art and boat-design support this.

Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


England Jon Entine Secret History of the Cherokee Indians Acadians Horatio Cushman epigenetics ethnic markers haplogroup N Freemont Indians Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) Rutgers University haplogroup D American history Basques Sasquatch Genex Diagnostics Bryony Jones Richard Buckley Virginia genealogy Sorbs Normans Hohokam Indians Patagonia National Geographic Daily News Belgium Richard III Egyptians Texas A&M University Ethel Cox autosomal DNA Terry Gross mutation rate andrew solomon Hispanic ancestry David Cornish District of Columbia Marija Gimbutas Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans BATWING haplogroup T Chauvet cave paintings National Health Laboratories Sir Joshua Reynolds Gregory Mendel hoaxes Hohokam race Barnard College Joel E. Harris horizontal inheritance Richmond California aliyah Melungeon Movement Victor Hugo Hopi Indians Penny Ferguson religion Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama Hadassah Magazine Phillipe Charlier surnames origins of art population genetics Rich Crankshaw haplogroup U Bigfoot peopling of the Americas seafaring NPR Britain William Byrd Arizona State University Ireland Roma People single nucleotide polymorphism Daily News and Analysis Yates surname haplogroup B Irish Central Joseph Andrew Park Wilson Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act Ron Janke private allele DNA magazine Old Souls in a New World Jesse Montes Alia Garcia-Ureste DNA Fingerprint Test admixture Kate Wong Current Anthropology Panther's Lodge Publishers Taino Indians genomics labs The Calalus Texts Y chromosomal haplogroups Stony Creek Baptist Church Pueblo Indians Discovery Channel mitochondrial DNA Bulgaria King Arthur Life Technologies DNA testing companies Mucogee Creeks Mark Thomas Cornwall haplogroup E Micmac Indians Monya Baker Jewish contribution to world literature Jewish novelists Slovakia Shlomo Sand Gila River Stephen A. Leon human migrations Stone Age N. Brent Kennedy London Sizemore Indians Ananya Mandal immunology Israel New Mexico Lab Corp Discover magazine Anacostia Indians James Shoemaker Rafael Falk Tom Martin Scroft Jan Ravenspirit Franz myths haplogroup L Ripan Malhi Jalisco Sinti Douglas C. Wallace Bode Technology Asiatic Echoes Smithsonian Magazine Roberta Estes Navajo Pomponia Graecina Middle Eastern DNA Germany Maronites Timothy Bestor Epigraphic Society haplogroup R Michael Schwartz North Carolina Lithuania George van der Merwede cancer Douglas Preston Comanche Indians prehistory family history Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Teresa Panther-Yates Mary Kugler MHC Richard Dewhurst consanguinity statistics Algonquian Indians Mohawk Henry IV Black Irish Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute Irish DNA Paleolithic Age Waynesboro Pennsylvania prehistoric art archeology Colin Renfrew Olmec X chromosome Denisovans Colima Maya Daniel Defoe Science magazine Nayarit Sarmatians haplogroup X Virginia DeMarce Genie Milgrom Colin Pitchfork Pima Indians Eric Wayner George Starr-Bresette Luca Pagani Abraham Lincoln Nova Scotia Stephen Oppenheimer Zuni Indians Bill Tiffee research India Hertfordshire Walter Plecker HapMap Patrick Pynes clinical chemistry haplogroup W Charles Perou Jews oncology personal genomics Melungeon Heritage Association haplogroup J Cherokee DNA Panther's Lodge DNA security Mother Qualla powwows rapid DNA testing Anglo-Saxons education Robinson Crusoe Antonio Torroni Theodore Steinberg Columbia University French DNA Native American DNA Test megapopulations methylation Cleopatra Anasazi pheromones John Wilwol Y chromosome DNA Phoenix university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Gunnar Thompson corn Etruscans Henry VII Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis Chris Stringer Peter Parham Amy Harmon evolution Magdalenian culture Keros haplogroup G mental foramen history of science Irish history giants Riane Eisler Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America haplogroup H Fritz Zimmerman Leicester El Paso Asiatic Fathers of America alleles ISOGG Khazars haplogroup Z Tucson crosses human leukocyte antigens AP Maui Havasupai Indians Kennewick Man Melungeon Union Celts Melungeons Zizmer Cave art Carl Zimmer GlobalFiler bar mitzvah First Peoples rock art Tucson Thuya Jim Bentley Harold Sterling Gladwin Sonora news Tintagel Chuetas Nature Communications New York Times Altai Turks Phyllis Starnes health and medicine anthropology haplogroup M Dienekes Anthropology Blog Patrick Henry polydactylism Chris Tyler-Smith Ancestry.com Nancy Gentry Finnish people CODIS markers Wikipedia pipe carving Navajo Indians DNA Fingerprint Test European DNA Charlotte Harris Reese Cancer Genome Atlas Wales Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies FOX News Arizona Khoisan Michoacan Phoenicians Joseph Jacobs Muslims in American history Odessa Shields Cox climate change Silverbell Artifacts Washington D.C. Scientific American Salt River Sea Peoples Bradshaw Foundation University of Leicester mummies Thruston Tablet Italy Satoshi Horai Ostenaco Michael Grant Mark Stoneking breast cancer Majorca Pueblo Grande Museum Caucasian King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Sam Kean palatal tori genetic determinism Henriette Mertz forensics Population genetics Rush Limbaugh Barack Obama PNAS Plato Ari Plost DNA Forums Clovis Choctaw Indians Holocaust Database Middle Ages Russia ged.com Grim Sleeper Tennessee When Scotland Was Jewish human leukocyte testing FBI ethnicity Arabia Asian DNA b'nei anousim Scotland National Museum of Natural History Family Tree DNA Les Miserables 23andme Bureau of Indian Affairs Eske Willerslev Early Jews of England and Wales Arabic FDA familial Mediterranean fever Oxford Journal of Evolution Tutankamun Zionism New York Academy of Sciences Juanita Sims Donald N. Yates DNA Diagnostics Center Gustavo Ramirez Calderon Cherokee Freedmen El Castillo cave paintings Turkic DNA Miguel Gonzalez M. J. Harper phenotype Cismar Cree Indians Ziesmer, Zizmor ENFSI Holocaust Melanesians medicine Central Band of Cherokees Bryan Sykes Bentley surname research Indian Territory Genome Sciences Building Oxford Nanopore Smithsonian Institution North African DNA Israel, Shlomo Sand Native American DNA haplogroup C Indo-Europeans Black Dutch Elvis Presley DNA Sizemore surname Lebanon DNA databases Elizabeth C. Hirschman gedmatch New York Review of Books Central Band of Cherokee hominids Austro-Hungary Svante Paabo Russell Belk Marie Cheng French Canadians Moundbuilders Cohen Modal Haplotype Mary Settegast Nikola Tesla Albert Einstein College of Medicine INORA far from the tree Mildred Gentry The Nation magazine Anne C. Stone genetic memory genetics Puerto Rico Philippa Langley Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid Abenaki Indians Dragging Canoe Akhenaten ancient DNA Alec Jeffreys Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America Cismaru Tifaneg Douglas Owsley population isolates Constantine Rafinesque American Journal of Human Genetics Monica Sanowar Anne Marie Fine Jewish GenWeb Romania Melba Ketchum James Stritzel Ashkenazi Jews Harry Ostrer EURO DNA Fingerprint Test Elzina Grimwood Nadia Abu El-Haj Jewish genetics Richard Lewontin Iran Europe B'nai Abraham Applied Epistemology Janet Lewis Crain Nature Genetics crypto-Jews Ukraine John Ruskamp Mexico Greeks genealogy Jack Goins Erika Chek Hayden art history Cherokee DNA Project metis Isabel Allende Beringia cannibalism Solutreans Sinaloa Stan Steiner Telltown Cooper surname Hawaii microsatellites ethics Promega Louis XVI Alabama Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma Bering Land Bridge Brian Wilkes Kurgan Culture BBCNews linguistics Helladic art Peter Martyr Rare Genes Myra Nichols Rebecca L. Cann occipital bun Kari Carpenter Cajuns Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology Gypsies Valparaiso University clan symbols Gravettian culture IntegenX Wendell Paulson John Butler African DNA Kari Schroeder Old World Roots of the Cherokee Neanderthals Kentucky China Wendy Roth Charles Darwin Elizabeth DeLand bloviators Johnny Depp Great Goddess Neolithic Revolution Stacy Schiff