If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


Review of Science Writing and News Reports on DNA Testing and Popular Genetics

Neanderthals Out of Anthropological Doghouse?

Tuesday, October 05, 2010

We predicted as much:  anthropologists are beginning to have a more positive attitude toward the role of Neanderthals in human prehistory. According to an article in today's Washington Post, "Scientists are broadly rethinking the nature, skills and demise of the Neanderthals of Europe and Asia, steadily finding more ways that they were substantially like us and different from the limited, unchanging and ultimately doomed inferiors most commonly described in the past."

The article by Marc Kaufman is titled "Anthropologists Adopt a More Favorable View of Neanderthals," and appeared in the October 4, 2010 edition of the newspaper.

Earlier research this year noted that Europeans have, on average, 1-4% Neanderthal genes. That began the wheels of scientific thinking rolling. "Our picture of Neanderthals is likely to change radically now that we know they were among ancestors of ours, not a dead-end, primitive race," we wrote in the blog post "Most Humans Part Neanderthal" on May 12. DNA Consultants introduced its Neanderthal Index in June.

Neanderthal woman.
Joe McNally/Getty Images and Adrie and Alfons Kennis.

An important paper that is helping restore Neanderthals' position in prehistory is "A Niche Construction Perspective on the Middle-Upper Paleolithic Transition in Italy," by Julien Riel-Salvatore (Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory). Riel-Salvatore also has a blog on prehistoric toolmaking and related subjects. Among his perceptions is that Neanderthal DNA was probably strong at first but got watered down in the course of time. That is confirmation for our targeting archaic populations to measure your Neanderthal Index.


writing homework help commented on 16-May-2011 08:12 AM

First of all, I would like to appreciate the effort that you have put in making such an informative blog. I enjoyed this post of yours and I must say that everytime I come back to your blog, I always have something new and informative to read. Thanks for
keeping me updated.

Steve C. commented on 28-May-2012 12:29 AM

Considering human history as we know it, I don't know if I can believe in the "peaceful coexistence" of Homo Sapiens and our burlier cousins. That Neanderthals were largely meat-centric in their diet would mean they would require much more territory per
capita than the more omnivorous Homo Sapiens. It would be in the interest of the more physically powerful Neanderthals to keep homo sapiens well clear of their hunting grounds, and they might very well have done so, for a while. But when the over-specialized
and the generalist meet, especially during times of wide climactic swings, the first are the more likely to lose out. The same patch of ground that could support one Neanderthal might support ten (or some similar multiple of) homo sapiens. It would seem that
the initial migration of Homo Sapiens out of Africa was a relatively small group, which would have given them reason to stay well clear of the Neanderthals (going east, not north). Once Homo Sapien populations had increased and they could more readily invade
and establish themselves in the same territory, Neanderthals would have had little choice but to pull up stakes and leave. The conflict, I suspect, was probably akin to that between humans and bears - while the individual human might have reason to fear a
bear it meets on a trail, it is bears, as a species, who have much greater reason to fear their demise at the hand of the human. Of course, one wonders if the Neanderthals, driven into the highlands and other less productive lands, might have making similar
resort to that which bears are prone to do today - raid our trash heaps and garbage dumps. In the case of the Neanderthals, however, I doubt they were trapped, darted, and relocated. More likely they were treated the same way the white settlers treated the
aborigines of Tasmania, who were hunted down and slaughtered like animals, every man, woman, and child.

Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


Maui Irish history Europe prehistoric art Applied Epistemology genetics population isolates Akhenaten Alabama Freemont Indians Chris Tyler-Smith rapid DNA testing mutation rate Charles Darwin Bill Tiffee Chauvet cave paintings haplogroup M Lebanon El Paso Peter Parham Neanderthals Richard III Melanesians Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans rock art human leukocyte antigens District of Columbia Altai Turks Silverbell Artifacts Comanche Indians University of Leicester consanguinity England b'nei anousim Cismar When Scotland Was Jewish Discover magazine Population genetics Asian DNA William Byrd seafaring BATWING Victor Hugo Richard Buckley Bode Technology Walter Plecker Middle Ages Mary Settegast Alia Garcia-Ureste Bentley surname research Maya Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Havasupai Indians George Starr-Bresette Olmec David Cornish Anacostia Indians news Ireland Rare Genes North Carolina Stephen Oppenheimer Douglas C. Wallace Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute haplogroup G Penny Ferguson Mother Qualla hominids Phoenix Oxford Journal of Evolution Jon Entine Cismaru Horatio Cushman Hohokam Indians Les Miserables Central Band of Cherokee Celts Gregory Mendel Sir Joshua Reynolds Irish DNA Navajo Indians Mark Stoneking Native American DNA Indo-Europeans hoaxes Zuni Indians Current Anthropology Life Technologies Bradshaw Foundation Israel aliyah Thruston Tablet Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies Anasazi pipe carving Stephen A. Leon alleles Rich Crankshaw DNA security admixture Virginia genealogy The Nation magazine haplogroup U North African DNA Cherokee DNA Project Dienekes Anthropology Blog Holocaust Tucson crosses autosomal DNA DNA Diagnostics Center methylation B'nai Abraham Scientific American Dragging Canoe Stone Age Caucasian Mildred Gentry Peter Martyr Cave art Abenaki Indians Nancy Gentry Bureau of Indian Affairs Nayarit prehistory Moundbuilders haplogroup B Panther's Lodge James Shoemaker Arizona State University Italy Nature Communications Richard Lewontin Central Band of Cherokees Waynesboro Pennsylvania Irish Central Mohawk Asiatic Echoes Puerto Rico Cree Indians Elzina Grimwood Yates surname Magdalenian culture Phoenicians surnames Illumina Sizemore surname Jan Ravenspirit Franz French Canadians Myra Nichols Hispanic ancestry Hadassah Magazine Richard Dewhurst Jack Goins Eske Willerslev genealogy haplogroup N origins of art metis Barnard College Nadia Abu El-Haj Shlomo Sand Clovis haplogroup J Sam Kean Roberta Estes HapMap Solutreans Isabel Allende Grim Sleeper Monya Baker Chris Stringer Paleolithic Age Wendell Paulson oncology race Albert Einstein College of Medicine Tucson Y chromosome DNA Bering Land Bridge PNAS New York Times Marie Cheng GlobalFiler Sinaloa far from the tree research Harry Ostrer FDA Sizemore Indians ethics Alec Jeffreys Jewish contribution to world literature Indian Territory Telltown health and medicine Ari Plost Cleopatra Colin Pitchfork Denisovans Sorbs New Mexico Kate Wong Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America FOX News Arabic Donald N. Yates M. J. Harper Joseph Andrew Park Wilson Terry Gross Eric Wayner Great Goddess Antonio Torroni single nucleotide polymorphism Colima Discovery Channel Tutankamun Miguel Gonzalez Epigraphic Society Gunnar Thompson Fritz Zimmerman horizontal inheritance Melungeon Union Virginia DeMarce Kurgan Culture Douglas Owsley Israel, Shlomo Sand Genome Sciences Building David Reich Germany Ripan Malhi First Peoples Riane Eisler Ananya Mandal Greeks Colin Renfrew Harold Sterling Gladwin Brian Wilkes Monica Sanowar Constantine Rafinesque IntegenX Philippa Langley Douglas Preston corn Pomponia Graecina Genie Milgrom Mark Thomas Gustavo Ramirez Calderon haplogroup W Keros pheromones Ostenaco human leukocyte testing French DNA Rush Limbaugh archeology Y chromosomal haplogroups Algonquian Indians DNA Fingerprint Test Cajuns Nature Genetics giants Beringia Svante Paabo Leicester Normans microsatellites immunology Russia Patrick Pynes Phyllis Starnes breast cancer Arabia George van der Merwede Henry VII Odessa Shields Cox Russell Belk National Museum of Natural History Janet Lewis Crain Wikipedia Jim Bentley Jesse Montes Rebecca L. Cann AP Bryony Jones Juanita Sims N. Brent Kennedy andrew solomon palatal tori Rutgers University Luca Pagani Cherokee DNA Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid mummies Bryan Sykes genetic memory Carl Zimmer Henry IV Abraham Lincoln Michoacan Scotland Anne Marie Fine Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act Cancer Genome Atlas 23andme Bigfoot Sea Peoples Columbia University Barack Obama Phillipe Charlier haplogroup C Micmac Indians ethnic markers ged.com John Wilwol CODIS markers Oxford Nanopore China Turkic DNA Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Cornwall Pueblo Indians Finnish people Satoshi Horai Slovakia New York Review of Books climate change Navajo Romania Ancestry.com El Castillo cave paintings Smithsonian Magazine Ukraine Cherokee Freedmen Tennessee BBCNews National Health Laboratories haplogroup D Chuetas Early Jews of England and Wales mitochondrial DNA EURO DNA Fingerprint Test Texas A&M University Joel E. Harris Tintagel Lab Corp King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Melungeon Heritage Association Joseph Jacobs Mary Kugler Jewish GenWeb art history Mucogee Creeks Sinti Wales medicine DNA testing companies Elvis Presley DNA FBI NPR Bulgaria powwows Iran ancient DNA Kennewick Man private allele Belgium INORA Muslims in American history Jalisco American Journal of Human Genetics Maronites Pueblo Grande Museum familial Mediterranean fever Taino Indians Kari Schroeder ENFSI Basques India Promega statistics crypto-Jews genomics labs history of science John Butler Black Dutch mental foramen Hawaii Jews Holocaust Database MHC Nova Scotia Robinson Crusoe DNA Forums Cooper surname clinical chemistry African DNA phenotype Sasquatch London Ethel Cox Patrick Henry Sarmatians haplogroup E Helladic art Etruscans Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma DNA magazine clan symbols Henriette Mertz ethnicity Asiatic Fathers of America Ashkenazi Jews Stacy Schiff cancer Nikola Tesla Gypsies Secret History of the Cherokee Indians human migrations Timothy Bestor Zionism Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis Louis XVI John Ruskamp peopling of the Americas Genex Diagnostics Melungeons Anglo-Saxons Thuya Roma People Family Tree DNA Valparaiso University Stony Creek Baptist Church Ron Janke Middle Eastern DNA Tifaneg Arizona Smithsonian Institution Washington D.C. Melba Ketchum haplogroup H epigenetics Native American DNA Test Wendy Roth National Geographic Daily News King Arthur James Stritzel Rafael Falk Michael Grant forensics Austro-Hungary Cohen Modal Haplotype Choctaw Indians ISOGG Amy Harmon Johnny Depp education haplogroup Z Black Irish bar mitzvah Charlotte Harris Reese Hohokam Michael Schwartz Hopi Indians Khoisan evolution Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) megapopulations Jewish genetics Old Souls in a New World Hertfordshire The Calalus Texts Mexico Pima Indians gedmatch population genetics Charles Perou haplogroup T haplogroup R occipital bun Erika Chek Hayden Neolithic Revolution Old World Roots of the Cherokee New York Academy of Sciences Science magazine Ziesmer, Zizmor Melungeon Movement Daily News and Analysis Acadians Plato Richmond California Britain Tom Martin Scroft Gravettian culture DNA databases Daniel Defoe Theodore Steinberg Patagonia Kentucky Egyptians Anne C. Stone Stan Steiner haplogroup X Zizmer Salt River linguistics X chromosome bloviators Jewish novelists Lithuania family history religion Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama Kari Carpenter genetic determinism Marija Gimbutas Teresa Panther-Yates personal genomics anthropology Khazars American history Sonora European DNA Majorca Panther's Lodge Publishers Elizabeth C. Hirschman haplogroup L myths cannibalism Gila River Elizabeth DeLand DNA Fingerprint Test polydactylism