If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


Review of Science Writing and News Reports on DNA Testing and Popular Genetics

Neanderthals Out of Anthropological Doghouse?

Tuesday, October 05, 2010

We predicted as much:  anthropologists are beginning to have a more positive attitude toward the role of Neanderthals in human prehistory. According to an article in today's Washington Post, "Scientists are broadly rethinking the nature, skills and demise of the Neanderthals of Europe and Asia, steadily finding more ways that they were substantially like us and different from the limited, unchanging and ultimately doomed inferiors most commonly described in the past."

The article by Marc Kaufman is titled "Anthropologists Adopt a More Favorable View of Neanderthals," and appeared in the October 4, 2010 edition of the newspaper.

Earlier research this year noted that Europeans have, on average, 1-4% Neanderthal genes. That began the wheels of scientific thinking rolling. "Our picture of Neanderthals is likely to change radically now that we know they were among ancestors of ours, not a dead-end, primitive race," we wrote in the blog post "Most Humans Part Neanderthal" on May 12. DNA Consultants introduced its Neanderthal Index in June.

Neanderthal woman.
Joe McNally/Getty Images and Adrie and Alfons Kennis.

An important paper that is helping restore Neanderthals' position in prehistory is "A Niche Construction Perspective on the Middle-Upper Paleolithic Transition in Italy," by Julien Riel-Salvatore (Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory). Riel-Salvatore also has a blog on prehistoric toolmaking and related subjects. Among his perceptions is that Neanderthal DNA was probably strong at first but got watered down in the course of time. That is confirmation for our targeting archaic populations to measure your Neanderthal Index.


writing homework help commented on 16-May-2011 08:12 AM

First of all, I would like to appreciate the effort that you have put in making such an informative blog. I enjoyed this post of yours and I must say that everytime I come back to your blog, I always have something new and informative to read. Thanks for
keeping me updated.

Steve C. commented on 28-May-2012 12:29 AM

Considering human history as we know it, I don't know if I can believe in the "peaceful coexistence" of Homo Sapiens and our burlier cousins. That Neanderthals were largely meat-centric in their diet would mean they would require much more territory per
capita than the more omnivorous Homo Sapiens. It would be in the interest of the more physically powerful Neanderthals to keep homo sapiens well clear of their hunting grounds, and they might very well have done so, for a while. But when the over-specialized
and the generalist meet, especially during times of wide climactic swings, the first are the more likely to lose out. The same patch of ground that could support one Neanderthal might support ten (or some similar multiple of) homo sapiens. It would seem that
the initial migration of Homo Sapiens out of Africa was a relatively small group, which would have given them reason to stay well clear of the Neanderthals (going east, not north). Once Homo Sapien populations had increased and they could more readily invade
and establish themselves in the same territory, Neanderthals would have had little choice but to pull up stakes and leave. The conflict, I suspect, was probably akin to that between humans and bears - while the individual human might have reason to fear a
bear it meets on a trail, it is bears, as a species, who have much greater reason to fear their demise at the hand of the human. Of course, one wonders if the Neanderthals, driven into the highlands and other less productive lands, might have making similar
resort to that which bears are prone to do today - raid our trash heaps and garbage dumps. In the case of the Neanderthals, however, I doubt they were trapped, darted, and relocated. More likely they were treated the same way the white settlers treated the
aborigines of Tasmania, who were hunted down and slaughtered like animals, every man, woman, and child.

Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


Melungeon Union Greeks Ari Plost immunology Panther's Lodge Publishers Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans Melba Ketchum Cherokee Freedmen Arizona State University ethnic markers Maya Cismaru Mohawk haplogroup W Alec Jeffreys New York Academy of Sciences b'nei anousim Irish history Nayarit Amy Harmon DNA security Family Tree DNA Oxford Journal of Evolution Louis XVI Great Goddess autosomal DNA Bering Land Bridge Dienekes Anthropology Blog North African DNA genetic memory Albert Einstein College of Medicine Thruston Tablet Mark Stoneking When Scotland Was Jewish Freemont Indians Paleolithic Age ethics rock art University of Leicester cannibalism haplogroup C corn Central Band of Cherokees Discover magazine private allele Texas A&M University Riane Eisler peopling of the Americas DNA Fingerprint Test Juanita Sims Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma ged.com Ziesmer, Zizmor Ashkenazi Jews Douglas C. Wallace Elvis Presley DNA Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute Navajo pipe carving Sorbs Antonio Torroni Turkic DNA John Ruskamp Wikipedia Bryony Jones Sea Peoples Daily News and Analysis Bryan Sykes Nature Genetics haplogroup J Zionism James Shoemaker Sinaloa myths China crypto-Jews Telltown Irish DNA alleles Sinti Britain Isabel Allende haplogroup X Alabama American history New York Review of Books Normans Navajo Indians Nova Scotia 23andme Nadia Abu El-Haj polydactylism Patagonia Harry Ostrer microsatellites familial Mediterranean fever Irish Central Micmac Indians Khazars Douglas Preston ENFSI Joseph Jacobs consanguinity Jim Bentley Scientific American Russia Choctaw Indians aliyah Peter Martyr George Starr-Bresette Stacy Schiff Jan Ravenspirit Franz Chuetas Genie Milgrom Stone Age Puerto Rico Life Technologies Applied Epistemology Algonquian Indians epigenetics Rich Crankshaw Jalisco Kari Carpenter Austro-Hungary Phillipe Charlier Tucson crosses gedmatch Ostenaco Joel E. Harris Current Anthropology Cohen Modal Haplotype Middle Ages Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America history of science Neanderthals AP haplogroup M giants Gregory Mendel Eske Willerslev Panther's Lodge Les Miserables Pima Indians NPR religion Constantine Rafinesque mitochondrial DNA Mucogee Creeks Roberta Estes Science magazine Gila River haplogroup U Timothy Bestor Gravettian culture Marija Gimbutas Lebanon Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies Bentley surname research Cancer Genome Atlas haplogroup T methylation District of Columbia population genetics Ireland Clovis Holocaust Satoshi Horai statistics Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis French DNA Native American DNA Test Miguel Gonzalez seafaring Mark Thomas Cree Indians oncology Hohokam Asian DNA PNAS Melanesians Penny Ferguson Henriette Mertz genealogy John Butler Patrick Pynes Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid Y chromosomal haplogroups Zizmer Lab Corp Charles Perou Ancestry.com personal genomics Virginia DeMarce El Castillo cave paintings George van der Merwede Oxford Nanopore Rush Limbaugh archeology John Wilwol Gypsies Abraham Lincoln Myra Nichols Mildred Gentry Plato genomics labs Iran mummies bloviators Sam Kean Virginia genealogy IntegenX haplogroup G Kurgan Culture African DNA Tucson INORA Anglo-Saxons New Mexico Terry Gross haplogroup E Janet Lewis Crain Cherokee DNA Project Horatio Cushman Smithsonian Institution Europe Tintagel Washington D.C. Sonora Jews ancient DNA Cajuns Basques Charles Darwin Bulgaria Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act haplogroup L Marie Cheng human leukocyte antigens human leukocyte testing human migrations James Stritzel clan symbols palatal tori Hopi Indians Jon Entine Peter Parham Hertfordshire haplogroup D Arabia DNA databases haplogroup R Black Irish Pueblo Grande Museum Bode Technology El Paso Eric Wayner Ripan Malhi Carl Zimmer andrew solomon Kennewick Man BATWING research Anne C. Stone Robinson Crusoe Discovery Channel Romania genetics Comanche Indians Early Jews of England and Wales genetic determinism Muslims in American history B'nai Abraham Jewish genetics Zuni Indians FOX News mutation rate Melungeon Movement Celts Cherokee DNA Havasupai Indians Odessa Shields Cox Phoenix EURO DNA Fingerprint Test DNA testing companies Chauvet cave paintings MHC evolution Tutankamun Illumina Khoisan American Journal of Human Genetics mental foramen Roma People Michoacan forensics Elzina Grimwood Middle Eastern DNA Bigfoot DNA Diagnostics Center prehistoric art The Nation magazine Theodore Steinberg Asiatic Fathers of America DNA Forums Hawaii Henry VII Black Dutch Barnard College European DNA Beringia Tifaneg Sizemore Indians Slovakia Hadassah Magazine Pueblo Indians First Peoples Nature Communications BBCNews Old Souls in a New World Charlotte Harris Reese Richard Lewontin Monica Sanowar Cornwall haplogroup H race Cleopatra Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama Acadians Central Band of Cherokee pheromones Denisovans FDA megapopulations Thuya Valparaiso University ISOGG Victor Hugo Joseph Andrew Park Wilson Richard III Kate Wong Finnish people occipital bun Indo-Europeans Mary Settegast Helladic art Bureau of Indian Affairs HapMap Belgium Mexico M. J. Harper Italy Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) Melungeons Epigraphic Society Chris Tyler-Smith Harold Sterling Gladwin Kari Schroeder Nancy Gentry Monya Baker National Health Laboratories Ethel Cox William Byrd Anacostia Indians Richmond California Dragging Canoe bar mitzvah Germany art history Stony Creek Baptist Church Jewish GenWeb Genome Sciences Building Rebecca L. Cann haplogroup N Columbia University Russell Belk Patrick Henry Svante Paabo Keros Promega news North Carolina hominids New York Times clinical chemistry Holocaust Database Luca Pagani Johnny Depp N. Brent Kennedy Henry IV single nucleotide polymorphism Jewish contribution to world literature CODIS markers Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Elizabeth C. Hirschman England Abenaki Indians anthropology Sizemore surname Sir Joshua Reynolds Salt River rapid DNA testing ethnicity Wendy Roth Moundbuilders breast cancer Rare Genes Richard Buckley Fritz Zimmerman Walter Plecker Gunnar Thompson family history Sarmatians Wendell Paulson Colin Pitchfork Douglas Owsley FBI Philippa Langley French Canadians Hispanic ancestry Native American DNA Cave art Altai Turks education Cismar Jesse Montes London Ron Janke Phoenicians Taino Indians Asiatic Echoes medicine Solutreans Ukraine Arizona health and medicine Maui Barack Obama haplogroup Z climate change Genex Diagnostics Grim Sleeper Michael Schwartz Kentucky Olmec Etruscans Waynesboro Pennsylvania prehistory Phyllis Starnes horizontal inheritance Population genetics Anasazi Melungeon Heritage Association Neolithic Revolution Old World Roots of the Cherokee Jewish novelists Anne Marie Fine Jack Goins Gustavo Ramirez Calderon Secret History of the Cherokee Indians Rafael Falk Silverbell Artifacts Donald N. Yates university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Israel, Shlomo Sand Smithsonian Magazine Yates surname Nikola Tesla National Geographic Daily News Bill Tiffee cancer Caucasian Mary Kugler Daniel Defoe David Reich Alia Garcia-Ureste David Cornish Tennessee Colima Chris Stringer Hohokam Indians hoaxes metis Leicester Maronites Shlomo Sand far from the tree Akhenaten Pomponia Graecina surnames Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology powwows Arabic National Museum of Natural History linguistics Israel Colin Renfrew Tom Martin Scroft Richard Dewhurst Rutgers University DNA magazine origins of art Stephen Oppenheimer Wales Bradshaw Foundation DNA Fingerprint Test Stephen A. Leon Stan Steiner Indian Territory Michael Grant admixture Y chromosome DNA The Calalus Texts Egyptians Elizabeth DeLand population isolates Scotland phenotype Magdalenian culture Sasquatch Ananya Mandal GlobalFiler Mother Qualla Erika Chek Hayden King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Teresa Panther-Yates X chromosome King Arthur Lithuania Cooper surname haplogroup B Majorca India Brian Wilkes