If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


review of scientific and news articles on dna testing and popular genetics

Neanderthals Out of Anthropological Doghouse?

Tuesday, October 05, 2010

We predicted as much:  anthropologists are beginning to have a more positive attitude toward the role of Neanderthals in human prehistory. According to an article in today's Washington Post, "Scientists are broadly rethinking the nature, skills and demise of the Neanderthals of Europe and Asia, steadily finding more ways that they were substantially like us and different from the limited, unchanging and ultimately doomed inferiors most commonly described in the past."

The article by Marc Kaufman is titled "Anthropologists Adopt a More Favorable View of Neanderthals," and appeared in the October 4, 2010 edition of the newspaper.

Earlier research this year noted that Europeans have, on average, 1-4% Neanderthal genes. That began the wheels of scientific thinking rolling. "Our picture of Neanderthals is likely to change radically now that we know they were among ancestors of ours, not a dead-end, primitive race," we wrote in the blog post "Most Humans Part Neanderthal" on May 12. DNA Consultants introduced its Neanderthal Index in June.

Neanderthal woman.
Joe McNally/Getty Images and Adrie and Alfons Kennis.

An important paper that is helping restore Neanderthals' position in prehistory is "A Niche Construction Perspective on the Middle-Upper Paleolithic Transition in Italy," by Julien Riel-Salvatore (Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory). Riel-Salvatore also has a blog on prehistoric toolmaking and related subjects. Among his perceptions is that Neanderthal DNA was probably strong at first but got watered down in the course of time. That is confirmation for our targeting archaic populations to measure your Neanderthal Index.


writing homework help commented on 16-May-2011 08:12 AM

First of all, I would like to appreciate the effort that you have put in making such an informative blog. I enjoyed this post of yours and I must say that everytime I come back to your blog, I always have something new and informative to read. Thanks for
keeping me updated.

Steve C. commented on 28-May-2012 12:29 AM

Considering human history as we know it, I don't know if I can believe in the "peaceful coexistence" of Homo Sapiens and our burlier cousins. That Neanderthals were largely meat-centric in their diet would mean they would require much more territory per
capita than the more omnivorous Homo Sapiens. It would be in the interest of the more physically powerful Neanderthals to keep homo sapiens well clear of their hunting grounds, and they might very well have done so, for a while. But when the over-specialized
and the generalist meet, especially during times of wide climactic swings, the first are the more likely to lose out. The same patch of ground that could support one Neanderthal might support ten (or some similar multiple of) homo sapiens. It would seem that
the initial migration of Homo Sapiens out of Africa was a relatively small group, which would have given them reason to stay well clear of the Neanderthals (going east, not north). Once Homo Sapien populations had increased and they could more readily invade
and establish themselves in the same territory, Neanderthals would have had little choice but to pull up stakes and leave. The conflict, I suspect, was probably akin to that between humans and bears - while the individual human might have reason to fear a
bear it meets on a trail, it is bears, as a species, who have much greater reason to fear their demise at the hand of the human. Of course, one wonders if the Neanderthals, driven into the highlands and other less productive lands, might have making similar
resort to that which bears are prone to do today - raid our trash heaps and garbage dumps. In the case of the Neanderthals, however, I doubt they were trapped, darted, and relocated. More likely they were treated the same way the white settlers treated the
aborigines of Tasmania, who were hunted down and slaughtered like animals, every man, woman, and child.

Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


haplogroup L John Ruskamp bloviators Indo-Europeans Jalisco Israel Chris Tyler-Smith Mucogee Creeks aliyah New York Times Colin Pitchfork Romania clinical chemistry Luca Pagani Zionism Italy Moundbuilders Douglas Preston Altai Turks familial Mediterranean fever Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America Victor Hugo Irish DNA DNA Diagnostics Center Chauvet cave paintings Cherokee Freedmen Hopi Indians Melungeon Union andrew solomon population genetics Melanesians Elizabeth C. Hirschman Henry IV Arabia Panther's Lodge Publishers Shlomo Sand Y chromosomal haplogroups Ukraine Walter Plecker Freemont Indians Leicester American Journal of Human Genetics Hertfordshire Nancy Gentry climate change religion Harold Sterling Gladwin microsatellites Henriette Mertz Asian DNA Sizemore surname Zuni Indians Germany Kentucky crypto-Jews Svante Paabo George van der Merwede Anne C. Stone Waynesboro Pennsylvania DNA security Bureau of Indian Affairs Native American DNA Test India Joel E. Harris Austro-Hungary Karenn Worstell Harold Goodwin AP El Castillo cave paintings hoaxes Tintagel Grim Sleeper Antonio Torroni Basques Navajo North Carolina haplogroup Z Theodore Steinberg oncology powwows Rich Crankshaw M. J. Harper Stan Steiner human leukocyte antigens Magdalenian culture Asiatic Fathers of America Bentley surname research Columbia University haplogroup E Navajo Indians Ancestry.com Mexico Johnny Depp Bryan Sykes Denisovans Etruscans DNA Fingerprint Test Gravettian culture Asiatic Echoes John Wilwol mutation rate Ethel Cox Native American DNA corn haplogroup X Eric Wayner Virginia DeMarce Richard Lewontin Israel, Shlomo Sand Greeks ged.com PNAS Horatio Cushman Kurgan Culture China Thuya Bryony Jones occipital bun Erika Chek Hayden 23andme Life Technologies Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) Nadia Abu El-Haj Daniel Defoe statistics Tennessee mitochondrial DNA Nayarit Paleolithic Age Anasazi N. Brent Kennedy Genome Sciences Building Jon Entine Charles Perou Discovery Channel archeology prehistory NPR Patrick Pynes clan symbols Henry VII Les Miserables Cancer Genome Atlas London Jewish genetics Joseph Jacobs EURO DNA Fingerprint Test polydactylism Egyptians haplogroup M Khazars Richard Dewhurst epigenetics Y chromosome DNA Beringia Cohen Modal Haplotype megapopulations Holocaust Database Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies Constantine Rafinesque Janet Lewis Crain Texas A&M University Acadians Europe Tutankamun DNA Forums surnames peopling of the Americas Indian Territory Cave art Amy Harmon prehistoric art Daily News and Analysis Epigraphic Society Nikola Tesla genetic memory Riane Eisler Sea Peoples French DNA mental foramen origins of art Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute palatal tori Gypsies Wikipedia Bulgaria Gila River Maui Carl Zimmer human migrations Mother Qualla ancient DNA metis Phillipe Charlier Great Goddess National Health Laboratories news admixture B'nai Abraham Middle Ages Middle Eastern DNA New Mexico DNA Fingerprint Test Cooper surname breast cancer Secret History of the Cherokee Indians anthropology Charlotte Harris Reese human leukocyte testing mummies horizontal inheritance Rush Limbaugh Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis rock art methylation single nucleotide polymorphism Timothy Bestor DNA testing companies hominids Arizona Monica Sanowar Salt River Telltown King Arthur Maya Pueblo Grande Museum Elizabeth DeLand Rare Genes Panther's Lodge Chuetas Robinson Crusoe Solutreans Bering Land Bridge Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid bar mitzvah Peter Parham haplogroup N Cherokee DNA Project Choctaw Indians ethnic markers Taino Indians Anne Marie Fine giants Lab Corp Marija Gimbutas research Jan Ravenspirit Franz Central Band of Cherokee Plato Ari Plost cancer haplogroup B Sir Joshua Reynolds Jone Entine Melungeon Heritage Association Elzina Grimwood Pueblo Indians Current Anthropology FBI seafaring Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology Oxford Nanopore HapMap personal genomics haplogroup H Albert Einstein College of Medicine gedmatch Melungeons Richard Buckley Roma People Douglas C. Wallace Sasquatch Micmac Indians IntegenX haplogroup T Kari Schroeder Rutgers University Mary Kugler African DNA Mildred Gentry population isolates Wendy Roth Jim Bentley The Nation magazine Brian Wilkes Elvis Presley DNA Ron Janke Barack Obama Finnish people forensics Arabic Dragging Canoe Black Dutch Philippa Langley Hispanic ancestry Old Souls in a New World Colin Renfrew Fritz Zimmerman Pomponia Graecina James Shoemaker Louis XVI Yates surname Stephen Oppenheimer Stony Creek Baptist Church Hohokam myths Ashkenazi Jews haplogroup D ENFSI Jewish GenWeb Cismaru Miguel Gonzalez Satoshi Horai Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma Michoacan Mark Thomas George Starr-Bresette Melba Ketchum family history immunology Thruston Tablet Lithuania Terry Gross Slovakia ethics far from the tree Cismar Abraham Lincoln King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Sorbs Muslims in American history Virginia genealogy Irish Central Smithsonian Institution Olmec Kate Wong Scientific American Washington D.C. DNA magazine Isabel Allende Comanche Indians Alec Jeffreys Michael Schwartz Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act phenotype University of Leicester American history Gregory Mendel Charles Darwin Cajuns Nature Communications Scotland consanguinity Ziesmer, Zizmor Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans Russell Belk Belgium Ostenaco Lebanon Black Irish Sinti Abenaki Indians Bode Technology ethnicity Peter Martyr James Stritzel Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Anacostia Indians Rafael Falk England Mark Stoneking Cornwall Phyllis Starnes Bradshaw Foundation Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America Genex Diagnostics Population genetics Donald N. Yates Sizemore Indians Turkic DNA INORA history of science Gunnar Thompson Juanita Sims Arizona State University Jewish novelists Wendell Paulson Tom Martin Scroft Richmond California Melungeon Movement private allele Phoenicians Harry Ostrer Caucasian Algonquian Indians evolution David Cornish Rebecca L. Cann Jewish contribution to world literature When Scotland Was Jewish Sonora rapid DNA testing haplogroup U Jews New York Review of Books Majorca FDA Applied Epistemology Khoisan Keros Irish history Michael Grant haplogroup C pipe carving Old World Roots of the Cherokee Havasupai Indians Ireland Neolithic Revolution DNA databases cannibalism university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Ripan Malhi Teresa Panther-Yates Kari Carpenter Mohawk Russia Douglas Owsley haplogroup J Promega Bigfoot health and medicine Marie Cheng Iran Central Band of Cherokees Eske Willerslev Oxford Journal of Evolution North African DNA alleles Hawaii Bill Tiffee genetics Sam Kean Zizmer Tucson X chromosome Odessa Shields Cox Science magazine Neanderthals District of Columbia Joseph Andrew Park Wilson First Peoples Akhenaten Nova Scotia Richard III Hohokam Indians Pima Indians linguistics Mary Settegast Maronites Normans Holocaust Stone Age National Museum of Natural History Tifaneg Kennewick Man French Canadians Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama Monya Baker New York Academy of Sciences BBCNews Patagonia education National Geographic Daily News Valparaiso University European DNA Stacy Schiff Britain MHC Patrick Henry Early Jews of England and Wales Cherokee DNA Jack Goins haplogroup R William Byrd Smithsonian Magazine ISOGG genomics labs medicine Colima GlobalFiler Clovis art history Anglo-Saxons Penny Ferguson John Butler CODIS markers Family Tree DNA Chris Stringer Cree Indians Sarmatians Dienekes Anthropology Blog Discover magazine pheromones FOX News Helladic art Ananya Mandal Roberta Estes Celts Alabama BATWING Sinaloa Nature Genetics genealogy haplogroup W Puerto Rico genetic determinism Jesse Montes Barnard College autosomal DNA Wales Cleopatra Phoenix race