If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


review of scientific and news articles on dna testing and popular genetics

Rigged Genetics

Tuesday, August 23, 2011
If the facts don't fit the evidence
change the facts . . .

We always suspected the genetics community of clinging to stale dogmas and being slow to acknowledge emerging new evidence about American Indians. But we did not dream that their officiousness extended to changing the information given by test subjects to bring it into conformity with preconceived conclusions.

Not until we heard Marcy's story.

"Over the years, I've heard complaints that [a DNA testing company] is not really responsive when you have questions about unexpected results," Marcy said. "They usually suggest further testing, which of course, means more revenue to them.

"I've had some major disagreements with [a DNA testing company] over how they list results for mitochondrial haplogroup ancestral origins . . . . I found out they were taking dozens of T2's who had listed their earliest known female ancestor as being from America or the United States, changing this and placing them in the 'unknown' category. They claimed that because our haplogroup was designated European, our ancestors couldn't be from the United States!

"Now this was nonsense, because at the same time, they allowed people to claim other similarly-colonized western countries, like Cuba. It's my opinion that if participants list a country of origin for their earliest known female relative, that should be what is on the web page, not something assigned by [a DNA testing company] because as they told me, it may 'confuse people,' or contradict current scientific data.

"As a consequence [the DNA testing company's] publicly reported ancestral origins has nothing to do with our haplogroup's ancient Cherokee clan mother. The chips should fall where they may."

Now this is not professional behavior on the part of a DNA testing company and it prevents new findings from coming to light.

In a study of 52 individuals claiming direct maternal descent from an American Indian woman, mostly Cherokee, we found that they were unmatched anywhere else except among other participants. Haplogroup T emerged as the largest lineage, followed by U, X, J and H. Similar proportions of these haplogroups were noted in the populations of Egypt, Israel and other parts of the East Mediterranean.

DNA testing companies do a disservice to their customers and to science by failing to call results as they appear without doctoring them. It is time geneticists stopped bringing all American Indians over the Bering Straits and forcing test subjects into the Procrustean bed of outmoded theory.

For more on "anomalous" American Indian haplotypes, visit our Cherokee DNA Studies, now in Phase II testing.


Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


genetic determinism population genetics Gravettian culture Israel Robinson Crusoe Leicester haplogroup H university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Cherokee DNA Bill Tiffee IntegenX Isabel Allende Pima Indians Phoenicians Asian DNA Washington D.C. Egyptians Alec Jeffreys AP Holocaust Finnish people Hertfordshire Ashkenazi Jews Cooper surname New York Review of Books Smithsonian Magazine Roberta Estes DNA Fingerprint Test Rich Crankshaw Phoenix Havasupai Indians Sarmatians Black Dutch Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act DNA security Comanche Indians Indo-Europeans HapMap Germany Sorbs Rafael Falk powwows Life Technologies EURO DNA Fingerprint Test National Museum of Natural History Zuni Indians prehistory Eric Wayner Waynesboro Pennsylvania Chris Tyler-Smith haplogroup L horizontal inheritance haplogroup N Plato Cancer Genome Atlas Anglo-Saxons North African DNA history of science Smithsonian Institution Maronites Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis Marie Cheng Walter Plecker Old Souls in a New World methylation Jalisco epigenetics medicine Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) DNA testing companies Moundbuilders phenotype MHC Phyllis Starnes Arabia cancer Jon Entine Bryan Sykes Dienekes Anthropology Blog religion bloviators consanguinity District of Columbia Cohen Modal Haplotype bar mitzvah John Wilwol Albert Einstein College of Medicine admixture crypto-Jews NPR Constantine Rafinesque linguistics Ziesmer, Zizmor Charles Perou haplogroup T Fritz Zimmerman Nikola Tesla rapid DNA testing Patagonia Peter Martyr ancient DNA Grim Sleeper hoaxes Normans Cleopatra James Shoemaker PNAS immunology New York Times Slovakia FOX News population isolates clan symbols Monya Baker Cismaru Barack Obama Oxford Nanopore Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute BATWING genetics Stony Creek Baptist Church Jewish GenWeb Turkic DNA Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Harry Ostrer Ananya Mandal Nadia Abu El-Haj Melungeons Middle Ages King Arthur Paleolithic Age Choctaw Indians haplogroup U Promega Horatio Cushman Marija Gimbutas Tucson DNA magazine Secret History of the Cherokee Indians China Melungeon Movement anthropology Current Anthropology Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America Elizabeth C. Hirschman George Starr-Bresette Phillipe Charlier Carl Zimmer Jews Daniel Defoe B'nai Abraham First Peoples Kurgan Culture Hohokam Maya Lebanon Rutgers University Michael Grant Michoacan Les Miserables Erika Chek Hayden Colin Pitchfork Valparaiso University Russell Belk Alabama Italy Terry Gross Clovis haplogroup J Colin Renfrew GlobalFiler haplogroup E evolution human migrations England Cajuns Pueblo Grande Museum haplogroup B Russia human leukocyte antigens Chris Stringer Neanderthals Khoisan Europe Salt River Cismar Virginia DeMarce clinical chemistry Bradshaw Foundation Applied Epistemology Austro-Hungary Harold Sterling Gladwin Johnny Depp art history Algonquian Indians Greeks Henry IV Genome Sciences Building haplogroup M DNA Forums Yates surname cannibalism European DNA Chauvet cave paintings Khazars Celts Abraham Lincoln Elzina Grimwood Anne Marie Fine Michael Schwartz Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America Miguel Gonzalez alleles New Mexico Hopi Indians Wendell Paulson Jewish contribution to world literature haplogroup R John Butler hominids Bulgaria DNA Fingerprint Test Roma People King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales private allele Great Goddess Gunnar Thompson London Holocaust Database Etruscans Pomponia Graecina Sinaloa Arizona State University Tintagel French Canadians Stacy Schiff Harold Goodwin Colima Ireland Neolithic Revolution Magdalenian culture Timothy Bestor genetic memory Jewish novelists Black Irish Janet Lewis Crain mitochondrial DNA X chromosome Rare Genes Anacostia Indians Arabic family history Henriette Mertz Majorca mental foramen human leukocyte testing haplogroup X single nucleotide polymorphism archeology Denisovans FDA mummies Mary Kugler Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology Henry VII prehistoric art Anasazi Pueblo Indians Olmec Nova Scotia Monica Sanowar El Castillo cave paintings FBI Middle Eastern DNA Gila River Altai Turks Daily News and Analysis genomics labs Cave art Teresa Panther-Yates Keros Y chromosome DNA Richard Lewontin oncology Stan Steiner BBCNews Mary Settegast ethnic markers Y chromosomal haplogroups education Bering Land Bridge Sizemore Indians Kate Wong Texas A&M University pheromones CODIS markers Sizemore surname Kari Carpenter rock art Bigfoot French DNA aliyah race Melungeon Heritage Association Nature Communications Ripan Malhi Luca Pagani haplogroup Z National Geographic Daily News Charlotte Harris Reese University of Leicester seafaring Richard Dewhurst Scotland India Ron Janke Gypsies Irish history Riane Eisler Theodore Steinberg Scientific American Science magazine andrew solomon Kari Schroeder polydactylism Irish Central Melba Ketchum corn myths Sasquatch National Health Laboratories Melanesians Penny Ferguson Amy Harmon Bryony Jones Mark Thomas Svante Paabo Kentucky palatal tori Discovery Channel Freemont Indians Bureau of Indian Affairs Hohokam Indians Abenaki Indians Ari Plost Romania Panther's Lodge Publishers Population genetics Lab Corp Arizona mutation rate Discover magazine Muslims in American history Jewish genetics Belgium ENFSI peopling of the Americas Irish DNA Acadians personal genomics Early Jews of England and Wales Richard III Asiatic Fathers of America Solutreans Native American DNA Douglas Owsley surnames Shlomo Sand Stephen Oppenheimer Bentley surname research occipital bun Stone Age North Carolina Telltown American history Joseph Jacobs Akhenaten Caucasian Barnard College Sea Peoples Jack Goins ISOGG far from the tree Israel, Shlomo Sand Ukraine microsatellites Thuya Zionism American Journal of Human Genetics news Wales Wendy Roth Kennewick Man Helladic art Sonora research megapopulations Nayarit Oxford Journal of Evolution George van der Merwede Epigraphic Society statistics Tennessee David Cornish Charles Darwin Mexico Douglas Preston Lithuania Sam Kean William Byrd Wikipedia Jim Bentley Elvis Presley DNA Louis XVI Panther's Lodge Beringia forensics The Nation magazine INORA Columbia University climate change breast cancer M. J. Harper New York Academy of Sciences Nature Genetics genealogy Navajo familial Mediterranean fever Jone Entine Micmac Indians Peter Parham N. Brent Kennedy 23andme Philippa Langley Chuetas Melungeon Union Cornwall African DNA When Scotland Was Jewish autosomal DNA Gregory Mendel Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid Richard Buckley Basques Rush Limbaugh Tom Martin Scroft Native American DNA Test Britain ethnicity Patrick Henry Victor Hugo Tifaneg Bode Technology Donald N. Yates Sinti Zizmer Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies DNA databases giants Virginia genealogy Iran origins of art Tutankamun ethics health and medicine