If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


Review of Science Writing and News Reports on DNA Testing and Popular Genetics

Rigged Genetics

Tuesday, August 23, 2011
If the facts don't fit the evidence
change the facts . . .

We always suspected the genetics community of clinging to stale dogmas and being slow to acknowledge emerging new evidence about American Indians. But we did not dream that their officiousness extended to changing the information given by test subjects to bring it into conformity with preconceived conclusions.

Not until we heard Marcy's story.

"Over the years, I've heard complaints that [a DNA testing company] is not really responsive when you have questions about unexpected results," Marcy said. "They usually suggest further testing, which of course, means more revenue to them.

"I've had some major disagreements with [a DNA testing company] over how they list results for mitochondrial haplogroup ancestral origins . . . . I found out they were taking dozens of T2's who had listed their earliest known female ancestor as being from America or the United States, changing this and placing them in the 'unknown' category. They claimed that because our haplogroup was designated European, our ancestors couldn't be from the United States!

"Now this was nonsense, because at the same time, they allowed people to claim other similarly-colonized western countries, like Cuba. It's my opinion that if participants list a country of origin for their earliest known female relative, that should be what is on the web page, not something assigned by [a DNA testing company] because as they told me, it may 'confuse people,' or contradict current scientific data.

"As a consequence [the DNA testing company's] publicly reported ancestral origins has nothing to do with our haplogroup's ancient Cherokee clan mother. The chips should fall where they may."

Now this is not professional behavior on the part of a DNA testing company and it prevents new findings from coming to light.

In a study of 52 individuals claiming direct maternal descent from an American Indian woman, mostly Cherokee, we found that they were unmatched anywhere else except among other participants. Haplogroup T emerged as the largest lineage, followed by U, X, J and H. Similar proportions of these haplogroups were noted in the populations of Egypt, Israel and other parts of the East Mediterranean.

DNA testing companies do a disservice to their customers and to science by failing to call results as they appear without doctoring them. It is time geneticists stopped bringing all American Indians over the Bering Straits and forcing test subjects into the Procrustean bed of outmoded theory.

For more on "anomalous" American Indian haplotypes, visit our Cherokee DNA Studies, now in Phase II testing.


Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


haplogroup C Rebecca L. Cann Los Lunas Decalogue Stone Thruston Tablet New York Academy of Sciences Lebanon Cree Indians Anne Marie Fine Charles Darwin Brian Wilkes clan symbols Leicester ethnic markers New Mexico Hohokam Indians N. Brent Kennedy Nadia Abu El-Haj French Canadians Central Band of Cherokee Elizabeth DeLand New York Times polydactylism Gunnar Thompson Peter Martyr James Shoemaker Oxford Nanopore Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid Patrick Pynes Nancy Gentry First Peoples Louis XVI Stone Age Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans Joseph Andrew Park Wilson crypto-Jews Micmac Indians haplogroup J DNA Diagnostics Center Black Irish human leukocyte antigens Douglas Preston Victor Hugo Middle Eastern DNA Middle Ages Nikola Tesla Texas A&M University Genome Sciences Building Zionism giants Mildred Gentry Cave art ethnicity Plato Gustavo Ramirez Calderon Colin Renfrew haplogroup Z Sonora Wendell Paulson Tucson crosses Caucasian Erika Chek Hayden PNAS Douglas C. Wallace medicine Tintagel anthropology haplogroup L horizontal inheritance university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act Lab Corp Epoch Times haplogroup N Discovery Channel FOX News Michael Grant Albert Einstein College of Medicine Rutgers University Secret History of the Cherokee Indians Sea Peoples Holocaust Database Gravettian culture Britain Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Ron Janke Anglo-Saxons Ukraine Robert C. Hyde Michael Schwartz Pueblo Indians Miguel Gonzalez Slovakia ancient DNA Penny Ferguson Ethel Cox Kentucky Carl Zimmer Lithuania Finnish people HapMap Riane Eisler Douglas Owsley Theodore Steinberg haplogroup T Charlotte Harris Reese X chromosome statistics Maui Sorbs Asiatic Echoes Anne C. Stone news Sir Joshua Reynolds Hadassah Magazine Y chromosomal haplogroups Israel, Shlomo Sand Silverbell Artifacts Sarmatians Moundbuilders Walter Plecker haplogroup X haplogroup E pipe carving Ripan Malhi Iran Joel E. Harris art history Sasquatch Jewish genetics Virginia DeMarce Basques Monica Sanowar Elzina Grimwood human migrations Black Dutch Tara MacIsaac Chris Stringer The Nation magazine Magdalenian culture family history Shlomo Sand Stan Steiner Colima National Geographic Daily News archeology Melungeon Union corn religion Tutankamun Hispanic ancestry Rush Limbaugh Zuni Indians surnames Akhenaten African DNA Odessa Shields Cox genealogy Bryan Sykes Greeks El Paso Tucson Sinaloa occipital bun Austro-Hungary When Scotland Was Jewish Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma Cismaru AP INORA human leukocyte testing American Journal of Human Genetics Charles Perou Amy Harmon DNA databases Central Band of Cherokees Altai Turks Pueblo Grande Museum Neolithic Revolution Solutreans Joseph Jacobs mental foramen MHC mutation rate Alabama Waynesboro Pennsylvania Jan Ravenspirit Franz familial Mediterranean fever Melba Ketchum John Butler Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) b'nei anousim Y chromosome DNA oncology Mary Settegast Tom Martin Scroft Egyptians Bigfoot Marie Cheng FBI Maya bar mitzvah Richmond California Life Technologies Telltown Wales GlobalFiler DNA magazine Cooper surname DNA Fingerprint Test Science magazine rapid DNA testing Muslims in American history Mucogee Creeks Irish history Algonquian Indians clinical chemistry ged.com Richard Buckley Barnard College Patagonia Melungeons Monya Baker Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute Denisovans Maronites Europe breast cancer Barack Obama Sam Kean Pomponia Graecina DNA Fingerprint Test research Daniel Defoe European DNA The Calalus Texts John Wilwol Indian Territory Luca Pagani BATWING Jewish novelists Sinti Horatio Cushman Chauvet cave paintings microsatellites Mark Thomas Family Tree DNA Helladic art India forensics Ireland Satoshi Horai Epigraphic Society Pima Indians Arabic National Health Laboratories Chuetas Majorca gedmatch Bentley surname research far from the tree consanguinity Bill Tiffee Eric Wayner Promega Elizabeth C. Hirschman Jews Khoisan Eske Willerslev Ziesmer, Zizmor Gregory Mendel admixture Mexico Scientific American Choctaw Indians 23andme Anacostia Indians haplogroup W Myra Nichols Henry VII Cocoraque Butte Tumamoc Hill Arabia George van der Merwede cancer Jon Entine Zizmer Melanesians Jalisco Anasazi Kennewick Man andrew solomon Khazars Irish Central Turkic DNA haplogroup G Svante Paabo Dragging Canoe DNA Forums Charlemagne evolution NPR B'nai Abraham Arizona Elvis Presley DNA Salt River Early Jews of England and Wales London Cancer Genome Atlas Genie Milgrom private allele Scotland King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Bureau of Indian Affairs Hawaii National Museum of Natural History haplogroup B Comanche Indians Hopi Indians Genex Diagnostics pheromones Kari Schroeder Bryony Jones Richard III ENFSI genetic determinism David Reich Bradshaw Foundation Timothy Bestor EURO DNA Fingerprint Test Phillipe Charlier origins of art North African DNA Richard Dewhurst history of science New York Review of Books Current Anthropology alleles Mark Stoneking Jewish contribution to world literature Holocaust Wendy Roth Ananya Mandal Taino Indians Celts Peter Parham Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis Kari Carpenter Juanita Sims Roberta Estes Roma People James Stritzel Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama education Hertfordshire powwows Population genetics French DNA Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology Henriette Mertz Gila River Mohawk Jim Bentley Jack Goins Abraham Lincoln haplogroup M Nayarit Michoacan population genetics Bering Land Bridge Henry IV seafaring Terry Gross Teresa Panther-Yates China John Ruskamp Johnny Depp myths haplogroup D Virginia genealogy climate change ISOGG Richard Lewontin bloviators Stacy Schiff Ashkenazi Jews Keros Israel Constantine Rafinesque haplogroup U Mary Kugler Havasupai Indians Illumina Alia Garcia-Ureste Cohen Modal Haplotype hoaxes Asiatic Fathers of America palatal tori hominids Ostenaco Irish DNA Neanderthals Isabel Allende health and medicine Les Miserables Dienekes Anthropology Blog Grim Sleeper Panther's Lodge Publishers Stony Creek Baptist Church Tennessee Great Goddess Rich Crankshaw Beringia Patrick Henry Acadians George Starr-Bresette Puerto Rico prehistory mummies Stephen A. Leon metis Phyllis Starnes Clovis University of Leicester Ancestry.com Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America BBCNews Melungeon Movement genetics Cherokee DNA Native American DNA Mother Qualla Bulgaria Washington D.C. Old Souls in a New World Olmec methylation Applied Epistemology Paleolithic Age Panther's Lodge Russia Chris Tyler-Smith population isolates Rare Genes Jesse Montes David Cornish phenotype ethics Wikipedia mitochondrial DNA Fritz Zimmerman Daily News and Analysis Philippa Langley FDA Cleopatra Romania Robinson Crusoe Hebrew inscriptions Yates surname Sizemore surname DNA testing companies megapopulations Cherokee DNA Project personal genomics race Phoenicians Cornwall Melungeon Heritage Association Marija Gimbutas Cismar Smithsonian Institution Italy genetic memory Cherokee Freedmen Germany Old World Roots of the Cherokee Phoenix Janet Lewis Crain Harold Sterling Gladwin Arizona State University linguistics Columbia University North Carolina Kurgan Culture IntegenX Nova Scotia American history prehistoric art rock art Signal Hill Ari Plost Harry Ostrer aliyah England Nature Communications Normans immunology Hohokam autosomal DNA Freemont Indians Stephen Oppenheimer District of Columbia peopling of the Americas El Castillo cave paintings Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies DNA security Bode Technology Cajuns cannibalism Donald N. Yates Navajo Indians haplogroup R single nucleotide polymorphism Etruscans genomics labs Oxford Journal of Evolution Native American DNA Test Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America Alec Jeffreys Jewish GenWeb Abenaki Indians Russell Belk Tifaneg William Byrd Nature Genetics Colin Pitchfork Discover magazine M. J. Harper Kate Wong Belgium epigenetics CODIS markers Thuya Smithsonian Magazine Indo-Europeans Sizemore Indians Antonio Torroni Valparaiso University Holy Roman Empire Gypsies Navajo Asian DNA King Arthur Rafael Falk haplogroup H