If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


review of scientific and news articles on dna testing and popular genetics

Rigged Genetics

Tuesday, August 23, 2011
If the facts don't fit the evidence
change the facts . . .

We always suspected the genetics community of clinging to stale dogmas and being slow to acknowledge emerging new evidence about American Indians. But we did not dream that their officiousness extended to changing the information given by test subjects to bring it into conformity with preconceived conclusions.

Not until we heard Marcy's story.

"Over the years, I've heard complaints that [a DNA testing company] is not really responsive when you have questions about unexpected results," Marcy said. "They usually suggest further testing, which of course, means more revenue to them.

"I've had some major disagreements with [a DNA testing company] over how they list results for mitochondrial haplogroup ancestral origins . . . . I found out they were taking dozens of T2's who had listed their earliest known female ancestor as being from America or the United States, changing this and placing them in the 'unknown' category. They claimed that because our haplogroup was designated European, our ancestors couldn't be from the United States!

"Now this was nonsense, because at the same time, they allowed people to claim other similarly-colonized western countries, like Cuba. It's my opinion that if participants list a country of origin for their earliest known female relative, that should be what is on the web page, not something assigned by [a DNA testing company] because as they told me, it may 'confuse people,' or contradict current scientific data.

"As a consequence [the DNA testing company's] publicly reported ancestral origins has nothing to do with our haplogroup's ancient Cherokee clan mother. The chips should fall where they may."

Now this is not professional behavior on the part of a DNA testing company and it prevents new findings from coming to light.

In a study of 52 individuals claiming direct maternal descent from an American Indian woman, mostly Cherokee, we found that they were unmatched anywhere else except among other participants. Haplogroup T emerged as the largest lineage, followed by U, X, J and H. Similar proportions of these haplogroups were noted in the populations of Egypt, Israel and other parts of the East Mediterranean.

DNA testing companies do a disservice to their customers and to science by failing to call results as they appear without doctoring them. It is time geneticists stopped bringing all American Indians over the Bering Straits and forcing test subjects into the Procrustean bed of outmoded theory.

For more on "anomalous" American Indian haplotypes, visit our Cherokee DNA Studies, now in Phase II testing.


Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


andrew solomon Telltown haplogroup C news Egyptians Bulgaria Charles Perou Smithsonian Magazine University of Leicester Basques M. J. Harper Karenn Worstell race rock art Melungeon Movement Sizemore Indians Mildred Gentry Sir Joshua Reynolds Lab Corp Gunnar Thompson Douglas Preston Maui Pima Indians Michoacan Rich Crankshaw Population genetics HapMap oncology Mark Thomas Puerto Rico Richard III African DNA human migrations Mucogee Creeks Belgium Bradshaw Foundation Gila River Gregory Mendel haplogroup M Cajuns DNA Diagnostics Center Luca Pagani BATWING IntegenX Chuetas Sam Kean Ancestry.com X chromosome Discover magazine Yates surname PNAS New York Times Roma People Daniel Defoe New York Review of Books powwows Comanche Indians alleles ENFSI Ireland corn Panther's Lodge Clovis Tutankamun population genetics Brian Wilkes crypto-Jews Melba Ketchum Jalisco Romania Nadia Abu El-Haj family history James Shoemaker Rush Limbaugh population isolates Paleolithic Age Virginia DeMarce haplogroup N Hohokam Indians Ari Plost genetic memory New Mexico Black Dutch Joel E. Harris Holocaust Database Richard Lewontin pheromones occipital bun microsatellites Khoisan Current Anthropology Magdalenian culture Iran ancient DNA Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute American Journal of Human Genetics Scientific American Anne Marie Fine Ron Janke Erika Chek Hayden Anne C. Stone palatal tori Michael Schwartz mitochondrial DNA Maya INORA Plato haplogroup E Pueblo Grande Museum bloviators Tennessee Douglas C. Wallace Anasazi NPR Jan Ravenspirit Franz single nucleotide polymorphism Charles Darwin Tom Martin Scroft Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Fritz Zimmerman Britain Bryony Jones Genome Sciences Building Arabic Amy Harmon Nikola Tesla mental foramen Sasquatch Micmac Indians Navajo Indians Nature Genetics Denisovans Horatio Cushman Melungeon Union Kari Schroeder Isabel Allende Nature Communications Jesse Montes education New York Academy of Sciences Ripan Malhi Ethel Cox Cleopatra French DNA Sizemore surname European DNA Moundbuilders Shlomo Sand Keros Anacostia Indians Washington D.C. Mary Settegast Arizona State University Phillipe Charlier Beringia hoaxes Barack Obama Wales Penny Ferguson ethnicity Peter Martyr haplogroup L Phoenicians Constantine Rafinesque Teresa Panther-Yates peopling of the Americas Eric Wayner El Castillo cave paintings Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid Cohen Modal Haplotype Dragging Canoe admixture clinical chemistry DNA magazine Stony Creek Baptist Church Algonquian Indians Old Souls in a New World N. Brent Kennedy Caucasian anthropology health and medicine Douglas Owsley John Wilwol Jews Etruscans clan symbols Central Band of Cherokee FDA DNA security Middle Eastern DNA Miguel Gonzalez Phyllis Starnes mummies China Cherokee DNA prehistory DNA testing companies autosomal DNA prehistoric art Jone Entine linguistics genealogy Leicester Y chromosome DNA Science magazine seafaring Cherokee DNA Project Great Goddess Irish Central far from the tree Virginia genealogy Abraham Lincoln Dienekes Anthropology Blog Monica Sanowar medicine Zionism Oxford Journal of Evolution Charlotte Harris Reese Holocaust Turkic DNA Discovery Channel Russell Belk Phoenix Rafael Falk Juanita Sims Stacy Schiff Richmond California England cancer Elzina Grimwood history of science Elvis Presley DNA Cismaru Roberta Estes Jon Entine Gypsies Italy Wendy Roth Walter Plecker Acadians Israel immunology ethnic markers Jewish GenWeb Kentucky Monya Baker Lebanon bar mitzvah Cismar genetic determinism myths genomics labs Wikipedia Bering Land Bridge Early Jews of England and Wales Applied Epistemology Tucson Albert Einstein College of Medicine When Scotland Was Jewish ISOGG Taino Indians religion Mother Qualla Family Tree DNA Irish history Neanderthals George Starr-Bresette Navajo Valparaiso University Kurgan Culture Bureau of Indian Affairs Donald N. Yates Cooper surname Arizona haplogroup T American history Cave art David Cornish Central Band of Cherokees MHC Nancy Gentry Stan Steiner Patrick Pynes Altai Turks rapid DNA testing Middle Ages Stone Age Barnard College Satoshi Horai Black Irish National Museum of Natural History Richard Dewhurst Bryan Sykes Sinaloa Kate Wong Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America Nova Scotia aliyah horizontal inheritance haplogroup U Daily News and Analysis BBCNews Gravettian culture phenotype Johnny Depp Majorca Panther's Lodge Publishers Scotland Zizmer Kennewick Man Colin Renfrew Peter Parham North African DNA Elizabeth DeLand Michael Grant Timothy Bestor genetics Grim Sleeper Thuya King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Theodore Steinberg Hertfordshire familial Mediterranean fever Hawaii Bode Technology Colima Mary Kugler Marija Gimbutas polydactylism Cherokee Freedmen megapopulations 23andme Patagonia First Peoples personal genomics Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act Bill Tiffee Jewish genetics DNA databases Havasupai Indians Carl Zimmer Ananya Mandal Native American DNA Rare Genes George van der Merwede Mark Stoneking Native American DNA Test Sinti Elizabeth C. Hirschman Melungeon Heritage Association Jewish contribution to world literature Rutgers University university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Bentley surname research Russia climate change Finnish people DNA Fingerprint Test private allele District of Columbia The Nation magazine French Canadians Olmec haplogroup D surnames forensics Hispanic ancestry Waynesboro Pennsylvania Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies Hopi Indians Ashkenazi Jews Greeks Marie Cheng Wendell Paulson Choctaw Indians Asian DNA Normans Epigraphic Society Victor Hugo haplogroup Z Janet Lewis Crain FOX News Israel, Shlomo Sand art history Zuni Indians Melungeons Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) DNA Forums consanguinity Maronites Henry VII Jack Goins cannibalism human leukocyte testing Akhenaten Sorbs Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans Harold Goodwin Slovakia Pomponia Graecina Les Miserables Philippa Langley Patrick Henry Secret History of the Cherokee Indians FBI National Health Laboratories Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma Celts John Butler Pueblo Indians Alec Jeffreys human leukocyte antigens evolution Jim Bentley epigenetics Germany Chris Tyler-Smith Sea Peoples William Byrd King Arthur GlobalFiler Henry IV DNA Fingerprint Test Ziesmer, Zizmor Bigfoot Freemont Indians Stephen Oppenheimer Irish DNA Columbia University Svante Paabo B'nai Abraham Richard Buckley Solutreans haplogroup B Life Technologies Indo-Europeans Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America hominids archeology Sarmatians haplogroup W Promega Chauvet cave paintings CODIS markers Sonora Louis XVI Harold Sterling Gladwin Rebecca L. Cann Antonio Torroni haplogroup X London Lithuania Anglo-Saxons Melanesians methylation Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology Texas A&M University haplogroup H Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis haplogroup R origins of art Ukraine Cornwall Arabia Cancer Genome Atlas Oxford Nanopore Alabama haplogroup J Jewish novelists Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama statistics Salt River Harry Ostrer India Joseph Andrew Park Wilson Tintagel Kari Carpenter Odessa Shields Cox Neolithic Revolution Smithsonian Institution Asiatic Fathers of America Chris Stringer Genex Diagnostics Muslims in American history Y chromosomal haplogroups Colin Pitchfork North Carolina Mexico giants Austro-Hungary Europe Tifaneg Helladic art Nayarit Abenaki Indians Robinson Crusoe Ostenaco Hohokam research mutation rate breast cancer Terry Gross National Geographic Daily News Riane Eisler EURO DNA Fingerprint Test AP Joseph Jacobs ethics Henriette Mertz Indian Territory Eske Willerslev Khazars