If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!


Review of Science Writing and News Reports on DNA Testing and Popular Genetics

Rigged Genetics

Tuesday, August 23, 2011
If the facts don't fit the evidence
change the facts . . .

We always suspected the genetics community of clinging to stale dogmas and being slow to acknowledge emerging new evidence about American Indians. But we did not dream that their officiousness extended to changing the information given by test subjects to bring it into conformity with preconceived conclusions.

Not until we heard Marcy's story.

"Over the years, I've heard complaints that [a DNA testing company] is not really responsive when you have questions about unexpected results," Marcy said. "They usually suggest further testing, which of course, means more revenue to them.

"I've had some major disagreements with [a DNA testing company] over how they list results for mitochondrial haplogroup ancestral origins . . . . I found out they were taking dozens of T2's who had listed their earliest known female ancestor as being from America or the United States, changing this and placing them in the 'unknown' category. They claimed that because our haplogroup was designated European, our ancestors couldn't be from the United States!

"Now this was nonsense, because at the same time, they allowed people to claim other similarly-colonized western countries, like Cuba. It's my opinion that if participants list a country of origin for their earliest known female relative, that should be what is on the web page, not something assigned by [a DNA testing company] because as they told me, it may 'confuse people,' or contradict current scientific data.

"As a consequence [the DNA testing company's] publicly reported ancestral origins has nothing to do with our haplogroup's ancient Cherokee clan mother. The chips should fall where they may."

Now this is not professional behavior on the part of a DNA testing company and it prevents new findings from coming to light.

In a study of 52 individuals claiming direct maternal descent from an American Indian woman, mostly Cherokee, we found that they were unmatched anywhere else except among other participants. Haplogroup T emerged as the largest lineage, followed by U, X, J and H. Similar proportions of these haplogroups were noted in the populations of Egypt, Israel and other parts of the East Mediterranean.

DNA testing companies do a disservice to their customers and to science by failing to call results as they appear without doctoring them. It is time geneticists stopped bringing all American Indians over the Bering Straits and forcing test subjects into the Procrustean bed of outmoded theory.

For more on "anomalous" American Indian haplotypes, visit our Cherokee DNA Studies, now in Phase II testing.


Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.

Captcha Image

Recent Posts


Walter Plecker Sea Peoples mutation rate Promega Tifaneg Tennessee Mary Settegast Svante Paabo Grim Sleeper genomics labs Gregory Mendel Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America research Slovakia Tucson Ashkenazi Jews Austro-Hungary Anne Marie Fine Illumina surnames George van der Merwede Daniel Defoe Chuetas Stephen A. Leon mummies Elizabeth DeLand DNA magazine Odessa Shields Cox haplogroup H genetic memory Miguel Gonzalez Middle Eastern DNA El Paso Kurgan Culture Colima Mother Qualla hominids linguistics Stony Creek Baptist Church When Scotland Was Jewish Leicester HapMap James Shoemaker Anglo-Saxons prehistoric art Bryan Sykes admixture Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) Nikola Tesla Shlomo Sand Smithsonian Institution Elizabeth C. Hirschman Bryony Jones haplogroup X Pueblo Grande Museum Arizona State University Amy Harmon Kari Schroeder Louis XVI Nature Genetics immunology Muslims in American history haplogroup D Valparaiso University horizontal inheritance Stephen Oppenheimer Constantine Rafinesque alleles Kennewick Man BBCNews art history Charles Darwin Central Band of Cherokees Melungeons Y chromosome DNA Anacostia Indians Philippa Langley Cismar Discover magazine Panther's Lodge First Peoples Scientific American Panther's Lodge Publishers X chromosome Barnard College genetic determinism Sinaloa Early Jews of England and Wales Mucogee Creeks forensics Alia Garcia-Ureste King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Peter Martyr bar mitzvah cannibalism human leukocyte testing Neolithic Revolution Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman Thuya Irish DNA AP Marie Cheng Bering Land Bridge Majorca EURO DNA Fingerprint Test Stan Steiner London Peter Parham single nucleotide polymorphism Fritz Zimmerman Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama Italy Ron Janke Secret History of the Cherokee Indians Douglas Preston Bill Tiffee Ireland Roma People Beringia seafaring aliyah Current Anthropology DNA security Moundbuilders Gustavo Ramirez Calderon Juanita Sims Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid methylation Family Tree DNA Wikipedia Richard III Hispanic ancestry Discovery Channel American Journal of Human Genetics ENFSI history of science Maui French DNA prehistory David Reich Richard Buckley Gila River BATWING Harry Ostrer Life Technologies Charles Perou Jon Entine Riane Eisler Yates surname Tucson crosses Black Irish FOX News Michael Schwartz Lebanon Ethel Cox megapopulations Caucasian El Castillo cave paintings Cooper surname crypto-Jews Wales Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute climate change FDA Plato Monica Sanowar Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act Khoisan Zizmer Wendell Paulson Sinti Havasupai Indians evolution Egyptians Sarmatians b'nei anousim palatal tori Albert Einstein College of Medicine European DNA Erika Chek Hayden George Starr-Bresette Cohen Modal Haplotype ethnicity Barack Obama Phoenicians autosomal DNA Asiatic Echoes Johnny Depp Maronites Rutgers University Population genetics John Ruskamp occipital bun Cave art New Mexico American history Middle Ages Charlotte Harris Reese University of Leicester Cismaru Horatio Cushman microsatellites Anasazi Melungeon Movement Israel, Shlomo Sand pipe carving Russell Belk Science magazine Finnish people Elzina Grimwood haplogroup E Neanderthals Zuni Indians Greeks Victor Hugo ancient DNA Jalisco Douglas C. Wallace Romania Jewish contribution to world literature The Calalus Texts Germany epigenetics Zionism genealogy Anne C. Stone Isabel Allende Genome Sciences Building DNA Fingerprint Test myths Mark Thomas Hohokam Indians Choctaw Indians Carl Zimmer Wendy Roth Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis mental foramen MHC Sir Joshua Reynolds Denisovans Phyllis Starnes Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies Old World Roots of the Cherokee religion Ukraine DNA Fingerprint Test Harold Sterling Gladwin Keros New York Academy of Sciences Micmac Indians university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Janet Lewis Crain Iran Rafael Falk FBI news Les Miserables ethics Native American DNA Test Great Goddess Kari Carpenter familial Mediterranean fever Epigraphic Society haplogroup N Arabic clan symbols breast cancer polydactylism Henriette Mertz Phillipe Charlier Cherokee DNA Project Elvis Presley DNA Khazars Bode Technology Tutankamun Black Dutch North African DNA Applied Epistemology African DNA Helladic art Irish history Virginia DeMarce Patrick Henry Eric Wayner Holocaust Database gedmatch Luca Pagani Genie Milgrom Mary Kugler Navajo Clovis Jewish genetics family history Jesse Montes Hopi Indians New York Review of Books Puerto Rico Sizemore surname Chris Stringer giants Richmond California Hertfordshire Nature Communications Altai Turks corn anthropology Cherokee DNA DNA Forums Old Souls in a New World bloviators Y chromosomal haplogroups Monya Baker Smithsonian Magazine race archeology M. J. Harper Magdalenian culture Penny Ferguson PNAS ged.com haplogroup Z Belgium Russia Rich Crankshaw Myra Nichols private allele Stone Age England Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma Israel Melungeon Union Jan Ravenspirit Franz National Museum of Natural History personal genomics Bulgaria genetics B'nai Abraham Scotland Joseph Andrew Park Wilson Hohokam Mildred Gentry Solutreans Satoshi Horai haplogroup M Pueblo Indians Tom Martin Scroft Lithuania Melungeon Heritage Association consanguinity Douglas Owsley Gypsies Roberta Estes haplogroup W Native American DNA Telltown Freemont Indians oncology Paleolithic Age Teresa Panther-Yates Joel E. Harris Sonora India Alabama haplogroup J 23andme Britain Tintagel Gunnar Thompson Comanche Indians metis powwows hoaxes rock art Indian Territory Ziesmer, Zizmor Dragging Canoe population genetics Maya ISOGG far from the tree Kentucky NPR haplogroup C Michael Grant haplogroup G Nadia Abu El-Haj GlobalFiler Jack Goins Pima Indians Abenaki Indians ethnic markers Genex Diagnostics Taino Indians Michoacan National Geographic Daily News Sorbs Rebecca L. Cann Asiatic Fathers of America Ari Plost Henry IV Olmec DNA testing companies Patagonia Donald N. Yates Mohawk haplogroup B Joseph Jacobs New York Times Bentley surname research population isolates Rush Limbaugh Thruston Tablet cancer Stacy Schiff Arizona Daily News and Analysis Robinson Crusoe health and medicine French Canadians Waynesboro Pennsylvania North Carolina Bureau of Indian Affairs Celts Chris Tyler-Smith David Cornish haplogroup L Patrick Pynes Indo-Europeans Normans Antonio Torroni Ancestry.com Ostenaco statistics Columbia University haplogroup U Jim Bentley William Byrd Jews origins of art Marija Gimbutas IntegenX Colin Pitchfork Henry VII CODIS markers mitochondrial DNA Algonquian Indians Sizemore Indians Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America Sam Kean Brian Wilkes Europe Dienekes Anthropology Blog Texas A&M University haplogroup R Hadassah Magazine Cleopatra Pomponia Graecina Cajuns Bradshaw Foundation Holocaust andrew solomon rapid DNA testing Silverbell Artifacts INORA Richard Dewhurst Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology Rare Genes haplogroup T Timothy Bestor Navajo Indians education Cree Indians National Health Laboratories Melba Ketchum Cherokee Freedmen Virginia genealogy clinical chemistry Terry Gross Cancer Genome Atlas Hawaii Richard Lewontin Theodore Steinberg Jewish GenWeb Akhenaten Gravettian culture Turkic DNA Colin Renfrew Mexico peopling of the Americas Nayarit Sasquatch Eske Willerslev Nancy Gentry Kate Wong Etruscans Chauvet cave paintings DNA databases Arabia Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans The Nation magazine Alec Jeffreys District of Columbia DNA Diagnostics Center human migrations Bigfoot Acadians human leukocyte antigens Ripan Malhi Ananya Mandal China Mark Stoneking Salt River Phoenix Washington D.C. Cornwall Abraham Lincoln Oxford Journal of Evolution Nova Scotia James Stritzel Oxford Nanopore Central Band of Cherokee N. Brent Kennedy Jewish novelists John Butler Asian DNA King Arthur Irish Central Lab Corp pheromones Basques John Wilwol Melanesians medicine phenotype